Sunday, March 1, 2020

2020 SAVVAGE SCORES

Using the logistic regression model for estimating the odds of a legitimate pro-bowl nomination as featured by Football Outsiders in 2016, we can use a linear model to estimate the log pro bowl odds of every tight end combine participant from the 2020 drills. With these players' pro-day data coming in at a later date, there's a good chance that a couple players clear the 6% success threshold (as established by historical data). For example, assuming Albert Okwuegbunam can manage at least a 28 inch vertical at his pro day, we can conclude he's likely to clear success threshold of this model.

Name Height Weight Vertical 40 time Vert+Hgt Weight/40 log odds P(AP1)
Cole Kmet 78 262 37 4.7 115 55.7 0.35 26.20%
Albert Okwuegbunam 77 258 28* 4.49 105 57.5 0.07 6.54%
Stephen Sullivan 77 248 36.5 4.66 113.5 53.2 0.06 5.95%
Adam Trautman 77 255 34.5 4.8 111.5 53.1 0.04 3.50%
Dalton Keene 76 253 34 4.71 110 53.7 0.03 3.28%
Colby Parkinson 79 252 32.5 4.77 111.5 52.8 0.03 3.00%
Dom WoodAnderson 76 261 35 4.92 111 53.0 0.03 2.97%
CJ O'Grady 76 253 34 4.81 110 52.6 0.02 1.84%
Brycen Hopkins 76 245 33.5 4.66 109.5 52.6 0.02 1.60%
Devin Asaisi 75 257 30.5 4.73 105.5 54.3 0.02 1.48%
Charlie Woerner 77 244 34.5 4.78 111.5 51.0 0.01 1.18%
Harrison Bryant 77 243 32.5 4.73 109.5 51.4 0.01 0.85%
Josiah Deguara 74 242 35.5 4.72 109.5 51.3 0.01 0.81%
Charlie Taumoepeau 74 240 36.5 4.75 110.5 50.5 0.01 0.70%
Hunter Bryant 74 248 32.5 4.74 106.5 52.3 0.01 0.66%
Mitchel Wilcox 75 247 31 4.88 106 50.6 0.00 0.24%
*hypothetical pro-day value

While this model is still in the validation phase, we've had some promising hits in players like Travis Kelce, George Kittle, and Tyler Eifert (out of 25 players clearing the threshold). The fact that this model has identified the *only* two Associated Press 1st Team Pro bowl Tight ends since the inception of the model suggest this model is very good at identifying high upside tight ends.

Though it's moving the bar somewhat, the associated ordinal test (AP 1st team, 2nd team, no pro bowl) comparing eventual pro bowls of combine participants above the 6% threshold to those below does yield a statistically significant p-value (though the assumptions of that test may be a bit questionable due to the small number of successes involved).

Applying this to my dynasty football league, I'll be stashing players like Kmet, Okwuegbunam, and Sullivan and looking to acquire predicted successes from last year's combine like T.J. Hockenson, Noah Fant, Foster Moreau, and Kahale Warring.